Why Democrats AND Republicans Should be Screaming for Secure, Sealed Borders
Thursday, March 22nd, 2007By: Nathan D. Fox
Editor’s note: This is the third article in a continuing series by the author.
This is somewhat of a continuation of the Paradox of Politics columns. On the issue of illegal immigration, both parties seem to have legitimate interests in securing the borders. For the purposes of full disclosure, I will say that I am in favor of very secure borders. I believe that a full fence needs to be built on our southern border, in addition to the “virtual fence.” This “virtual fence” will be but a band-aid to the problem; however if it were proposed as a supplement to a complete actual fence, I would be completely on board. I know, let the name calling begin. Call me what you will, but it is in our national security interest, economic interest, and general well being as a nation to secure the sieve we currently affectionately refer to as our southern border. By definition, a nation is not a nation without borders. If we continue as we are, we will very soon go by Los Estados Unidos de Mexi-Americana.
Conservatives and Republicans (while not always synonymous, there is substantial overlap in the two groups, and this overlap is where I place myself on the political spectrum) maintain the strongest interest in closing the southern border. The main reason I vote Republican is for national security, and currently we are failing with flying colors with regard to our border with Mexico. Even if no “terrorists” have come through the southern border (which I doubt), just the mere possibility that they can come through should be cause for concern. And in case Republican politicians are wondering, their constituents (myself and many others included) are hoping that they are at least competent enough to get this done. However, it appears that Republicans are more inclined to care about big businesses that “rely” on illegal immigrants to work for substandard wages so they can profit. This should not be the case. In my opinion, the “boost” to the economy provided by illegal immigrant labor is far outweighed by the detriment they bring to this country via social services: education, free healthcare, and others. This is criminal. It is the equivalent of stealing.
Democrats should be getting beat up by some of their traditional constituents regarding this issue. Labor unions tend to be big supporters of Democratic candidates. Labor unions should be upset about illegal immigration because union shops are unable to compete with businesses who utilize illegal labor. However, this relies on the assumption that union shops actually have to compete for contracts and that government contracts are not doled out without corruption. I am sure Philadelphia does not have this problem! (If you are offended by my sarcasm, please stop reading, it will continue.) Another union, the NEA (National Education Association), should be absolutely incensed in places such as California, Arizona, and Texas. The public schools have to deal with the direct effect of too many illegals. Some schools actually teach half of a day in Spanish! How is that right to the American citizens who pay their taxes, and pay for the schools? Also, many American minority groups suffer because of illegal immigration. Sean Hannity has had guests on his radio and television program who make this argument repeatedly. Illegal immigrants rob opportunity from American citizens who have legitimately been subject to lesser opportunities. I know as a white suburban male I do not have the best credentials to be making this argument. However, it is a matter of economics 101. Without legislation and consequences, employers are going to give jobs to the lowest bidder. At many levels, this is having a direct effect on American minority groups.
All in all, the southern border’s lack of security is a prime example of bad American politics. Clearly special interests and pandering to potential voters has gotten in the way of our elected officials making proper judgments on this critical issue. I hope and pray that we can secure our borders before it is too late; assuming that it is not too late already. In the mean time, take a listen to Bill O’Reilly, Sean Hannity, Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck, Rush Limbaugh and in Philly, Michael Smerconish. All of these individuals do vary somewhat in their political views. However, one thing these gentlemen are all right (no pun intended) on is sealing our southern border. One thing we as Americans must be thankful for is “the new media,” as Sean Hannity says. Without the aforementioned individuals, most concerned Americans would be without representation on the airwaves, internet, and television. It is bad enough that on this issue those of us who want a secure southern border seem to be without representation or solid leadership in Washington; at least we have some media on our side.